Sir John Valentine Carden Survives. Part 2.

I heard something about the IJN and USN operating land forces in the Pacific theatre too. Apparently they weren't so crash hot. Light infantry on the whole. Vastly too much training time expended for light infantry. I don't know how someone can justify spending that much on light infantry given its relatively routinised military applications. It wasn't like they were used for a critical pathway strategy dependent operation or anything. Must have just been featherbedding and pocketlining.

Next you'll tell me that countries throw perfectly good over trained light infantry out of planes for them to die, horribly, surrounded by hostile forces on all sides.
 
I do wish that the correct Australian nomenclature was used. Australian Army units were identified only by a numeral, not by the suffix "st" or "first", therefore the 8 Division was known as "8 Division AIF" if anything. The same goes for cavalry units, they were known as "8 Division Cavalry Regiment" or "Squadron" not as "8th division Cavalry". As far as I am aware, 8 Division never actually had a cavalry regiment attached. Units with a suffix of "2/" were the second raising of that unit after it's first raising and disbandment after the end of WW1. They were specifically given that suffix to link them with their predecessor unit and to differentiate their exploits from their predecessors. 1 Armoured Regiment would be recorded as exactly that, "1 Armoured Regiment AIF" nothing else. This is important from an Australian perspective and helps to differentiate those units from British/Indian Army units.
 
When your Army hates your Navy so much they incidentally invent the Amphibious Assault Ship, that's Imperial Japan.

But, you know, they IJA did end up constructing its own dedicated Cargo Submarines, so it's actually impossible to say if Imperial Japan was good or bad.
I've heard the theory that this is because the IJA and IJN leadership recruited from two rival Samurai clans/families that had hated each other for centuries before the Meji Restoration.
 
I've heard the theory that this is because the IJA and IJN leadership recruited from two rival Samurai clans/families that had hated each other for centuries before the Meji Restoration.
Pretty sure that's not the case, as the Samurai were pretty heavily pounded in the Boshin War. I suspect it originated from the 1872 decision to dissolve the Ministry of War, and replace it with two separate ministries, one for the Army, the other for the Navy.
 
I do wish that the correct Australian nomenclature was used. Australian Army units were identified only by a numeral, not by the suffix "st" or "first", therefore the 8 Division was known as "8 Division AIF" if anything. The same goes for cavalry units, they were known as "8 Division Cavalry Regiment" or "Squadron" not as "8th division Cavalry". As far as I am aware, 8 Division never actually had a cavalry regiment attached. Units with a suffix of "2/" were the second raising of that unit after it's first raising and disbandment after the end of WW1. They were specifically given that suffix to link them with their predecessor unit and to differentiate their exploits from their predecessors. 1 Armoured Regiment would be recorded as exactly that, "1 Armoured Regiment AIF" nothing else. This is important from an Australian perspective and helps to differentiate those units from British/Indian Army units.
Not quite correct. 2/4th Armd Regt was not the second raising of the unit as there had been no 4th Armd regt previously. The 2/xx was to designate the 2nd AIF units, Those designated as being allowed to serve outside Australia or its territories. Later changed to allow none AIF unts to serve outside Australian territories up to IIRC the equator or something like that. Thus there were 6th Bn RAINF units in Australia while there were 2/6th AIF Bns in 6th Div AIF in Egypt.
 
Pretty sure that's not the case, as the Samurai were pretty heavily pounded in the Boshin War. I suspect it originated from the 1872 decision to dissolve the Ministry of War, and replace it with two separate ministries, one for the Army, the other for the Navy.
There was a lot of clan stuff still going on.

It's simplistic and lazy to blame a rivalry on old clan stuff but it can't be dismissed.

One the reasons behind the decision to split the ministries was because a big portion of military officers from the Satsumura clan resigned in protest of a political decision.

The Minister of War refused to allow them back into service. The ministry of war was split. The old minister of war or one his supporters stayed on as minister of the army. The new minister of the navy was Satsumura clan brought the officers who resigned (including the army ones) into naval service.

Now if you look at it with a certain view this incident is a clan objecting to a certain act. Humiliating a minister from another clan. Getting that minister demoted and transferring all officers from the clan into the navy which the clan then took over.

From another point of view someone was doing something bad politically. Got humiliated over it and threw a tantrum refusing the people who humiliated him back to the army. Then he got demoted. There was no formal clan actions.

That said there was a lot of people in the early IJA from one clan and the early IJN from another clan. These clans were previously rivals.

This could have been a factor feeding interservice rival but I really doubt it was the main factor.

Edited to add: Whether this was a key factor in the transition between a ministry of war and a minister for the Army and one for the Navy or merely a scandal going on in the background at the same time I don't know. I've see both claimed.
 
Last edited:
More like of a major factor than one of the main one I would say the old clans had their areas influence back in Imperial Japan and before in the Shogunate as well as their enemies and allies
 
Last edited:

Ramp-Rat

Monthly Donor
The question of where the British will base their fleet, instead of Singapore is to my mind irrelevant, at this time. The need for the British to find an alternative fleet base is predicated on Singapore falling, or becoming untenable. So unless Singapore falls or becomes untenable, the British will base their Far East Fleet, out of the extensive and expensive fleet base they built in Singapore. But you say, given that Singapore will be under serious aerial assault, how will the British be able to use Singapore as a naval base. Right deep breath, let’s look at the facts on the ground, in Singapore and the Far East in 1941/42. Do the British as they did in Britain, have a sophisticated and integrated air defence system, as they did in Britain, no. However do the Japanese have a strategic bomber force, along with the infrastructure and logistics to enable them to carry out a prolonged bombing campaign against Singapore, agin no.

Only two nations during WWII were able to develop a true strategic bomber force, and provided the extensive infrastructure, equipment, personnel and logistics to support it, Britain and America. All the other major airforces were basically tactical, with on a few occasions very limited strategic strikes thrown in. The ability to undertake a a long range strategic bombing campaign, required planning and preparation to have been undertaken years before the outbreak of the war. Only one of the allied strategic bombers wasn’t a prewar design or adaptation of a pre war design, the B-29. Only Britain and America were able to devote the resources needed to train the crews needed to man their bombers, it took two years on average to train a bomber crew, and required massive amounts of fuel and numerous aircraft, along with extensive ground facilities. Take just a pilot, he will require at least five aircraft and close to two hundred hours if not more, to be fit to undertake his first mission. Japan doesn’t have the aircraft, resources, logistics or facilities to engage in a strategic bombing campaign against Singapore.

It close to 1000 km over predominately water to fly from FIC to Singapore, and all such flights will be unescorted, even the famed Zero, couldn’t manage that. Until the Japanese are able to establish bases in Malaya, preferably south of Kuala Lumpur, they are going to be restricted to predominately unescorted raids. And thus will find that even the second rate fighters available to the British, early mark Hurricanes, with a few thousand hours on the clock, American Kittyhawkes, and even the much belittled Australian Boomerang, are more than capable of downing the Japanese bombers. And it needs to be remembered, just as with the German Luftwaffe during the Battle of Britain, every Japanese aircraft lost trying to bomb Singapore, is also a valuable crew lost too. And unlike the British, who have by now a well established pipeline of new crews and aircraft, the Japanese for a number of reasons don’t. The Japanese also have the problem that the best use of the limited number of bombers they have, is not trying to carry out a strategic attack against Singapore. The best use is as tactical bombers in support of the Army in China, where given the lack of opposition in the air or on the ground, I seriously doubt that a single Chinese devision had an anti aircraft battery. And there was a singular lack of civil defence services or effective civil control and administration in China. The second best use of the bombers available to the Japanese, is in tactical support of their ground forces in Malaya/Philippines.

The worst and least effective use is trying to carry out a strategic bombing campaign against Singapore. Unless the Japanese can carry out a single knockout attack, such as the Germans did against Rotterdam in 1940, that caused a total collapse of the establishment, the Japanese are wasting both their time and resources. Yes the first few raids on Singapore will cause much distress and confusion, with a degree of panic among the poor, not because the dam natives don’t have the backbone of the British. But because the air raid precautions are inadequate, and there are no shelters, for the locals or the British establishment. Singapore being low lying and the water table so high, it was impossible at the time to build underground shelters. However there are a significant number of second line troops in the city, not trained enough to be sent into combat, but sufficiently trained to ensure that the remit of the civil power, can be enforced. And once the administration gets a grip, and the population gets used to being bombed, and as with all civilian populations throughout the world, they will. Life, industry, commerce, and the general conduct of the war will continue, and adjust to the new conditions. If the Japanese can be held north of a line KL to Pahang, or even better and much shorter Penang to Kelantan, the Japanese will only be able to raid Singapore at night, and by April 42 be facing vastly improved defences. As without the serious drain of the conflict in the Middle East, more resources can be spared, and the local government will be more experienced.

Singapore will ITTL be the base for one of the two major fleets facing the Japanese, with Pearl Harbour being the other. The largest fleet will be the American Pacific Fleet, while the British Far East Fleet, will concentrate on operations in the South China Sea, and around the various British and Dutch islands. The major problem will be when the Americans request facilities for their relief of the Philippines fleet. Yes Guam is roughly the same distance from the Philippines as Singapore is, however Guam is an undeveloped island in the Pacific, and Singapore has in addition to one of the worlds largest natural harbours, and a significant local industrial base to draw on. It might be much further away from the Continental United States, but it will be able to draw on shipping from both the east and west coasts, plus what ever the Empire can spare. You could even see a two pronged attack from both Singapore and Guam.

RR.
 

marathag

Banned
Okay, this proves that the Japanese had the conception of a pretty modern amphibious warfare capability.
Lke the US Marines, few countries had need to try this in the Interwar era.
US observers saw what the Japanese were using for landing craft
1662301820340.jpeg

and Higgins boats were influenced by that, with both nations influenced by the larger X-Lighters the British used at Gallipoli
 
I heard something about the IJN and USN operating land forces in the Pacific theatre too. Apparently they weren't so crash hot. Light infantry on the whole. Vastly too much training time expended for light infantry. I don't know how someone can justify spending that much on light infantry given its relatively routinised military applications. It wasn't like they were used for a critical pathway strategy dependent operation or anything. Must have just been featherbedding and pocketlining.

Next you'll tell me that countries throw perfectly good over trained light infantry out of planes for them to die, horribly, surrounded by hostile forces on all sides.
Don't be silly. Why would anyone do that? The preferred method is to encourage perfectly good, over-trained, under-equipped light infantry, via a mix of training, propaganda & peer pressure, to throw themselves out of planes into an extremely target-rich environment. Or even crash said planes into said target-rich environment, on purpose.

Still, could be worse. Rumor has it some countries just hand weapons to construction workers, give them a modicum of training, and then drop them off on an island held by fanatical enemy forces, with instructions to build an airfield and/or port asap.
 
The situation in the TL at present (forgive me if Iive missed anything).

North Africa is in British and Commonwealth hands or in the currently playing nuetral Vichy French. It seems likely that the French on the ground would allow Italian and German forces to move in, even if they could get them across the Mediterranean and maintain them in North Africa. Malta is safe, ships can make it through the Mediterranean if escorted properly (with some losses). Create remains in Greek hands and there are Greek forces in training. These Forces along with the British and Commonwealth forces in theater (with not a lot to do) are likely to do some liberating of the Greek Islands over the next year while the amphibious capability to try something more ambitious is built up. This would likely mean a build up of Axis forces in mainland Greece to counter a real or imagined Allied invasion (up to Allen which way the Allies go as there plenty of good reasons either way).

Russia remains as OTL and although over the next couple of months the winter counter offensives push the Germans back, the spring will come and the snows thaw will heral the Germans to renew their invasion and no one in the West knows if Russia will survive.

In the Far East its reasonably safe to make some speculative predictions. Like OTL Doug Out Doug's performance in the Philippines (begrudgingly also lack of overall preparedness might also be a factor) mean the Philippines will fall as OTL. Britain thanks to having some proper tanks and veteran formations in the right places for a change likely holds (at least) Southern Malaya. The Japanese Burmese offensive (and the invasion of much of the DEI) is for the Japanese at best delayed and more likely called off until Malaya is occupied. This does alow the British (OK mostly Indians and Australians) the time to reinforce South East Asia.

In this scenario what does the US do? If they agree with the Germany first strategy where can they fight and when? There's no active fronts and an invasion of North West Europe is out until substantial forces are transported across the Atlantic. Side shows in the Mediterranean are an option with perhaps the assault on Sicily taking the place of Operation Torch towards the end of 1942. There's not even the OTL yoyo battles in the desert to give US equipment some testing and for politicians something to point at to show the US electorate what their taxes are doing to win the war.

But there's one active front where even small amounts of troups and planes (and in the spring of 1942 that's all the US Army had available to deploy) could make a big difference and that's Malaya and THE DEI! If the US do get involved this could fundamentally change the Pacific War. A major joint offensive to liberate Thailand and FIC before linking up with Chinese could be a viable (and arguably potentially cheaper in lives and material) alternative that the OTL island hopping campaign.
 
Hmm big advantage of the Burma invasion not going in is going to be that the Burma road will stay open longer for all the good it will do.
 

Ramp-Rat

Monthly Donor
The situation in the TL at present (forgive me if Iive missed anything).

North Africa is in British and Commonwealth hands or in the currently playing nuetral Vichy French. It seems likely that the French on the ground would allow Italian and German forces to move in, even if they could get them across the Mediterranean and maintain them in North Africa. Malta is safe, ships can make it through the Mediterranean if escorted properly (with some losses). Create remains in Greek hands and there are Greek forces in training. These Forces along with the British and Commonwealth forces in theater (with not a lot to do) are likely to do some liberating of the Greek Islands over the next year while the amphibious capability to try something more ambitious is built up. This would likely mean a build up of Axis forces in mainland Greece to counter a real or imagined Allied invasion (up to Allen which way the Allies go as there plenty of good reasons either way).

Russia remains as OTL and although over the next couple of months the winter counter offensives push the Germans back, the spring will come and the snows thaw will heral the Germans to renew their invasion and no one in the West knows if Russia will survive.

In the Far East its reasonably safe to make some speculative predictions. Like OTL Doug Out Doug's performance in the Philippines (begrudgingly also lack of overall preparedness might also be a factor) mean the Philippines will fall as OTL. Britain thanks to having some proper tanks and veteran formations in the right places for a change likely holds (at least) Southern Malaya. The Japanese Burmese offensive (and the invasion of much of the DEI) is for the Japanese at best delayed and more likely called off until Malaya is occupied. This does alow the British (OK mostly Indians and Australians) the time to reinforce South East Asia.

In this scenario what does the US do? If they agree with the Germany first strategy where can they fight and when? There's no active fronts and an invasion of North West Europe is out until substantial forces are transported across the Atlantic. Side shows in the Mediterranean are an option with perhaps the assault on Sicily taking the place of Operation Torch towards the end of 1942. There's not even the OTL yoyo battles in the desert to give US equipment some testing and for politicians something to point at to show the US electorate what their taxes are doing to win the war.

But there's one active front where even small amounts of troups and planes (and in the spring of 1942 that's all the US Army had available to deploy) could make a big difference and that's Malaya and THE DEI! If the US do get involved this could fundamentally change the Pacific War. A major joint offensive to liberate Thailand and FIC before linking up with Chinese could be a viable (and arguably potentially cheaper in lives and material) alternative that the OTL island hopping campaign.
On the question of if you missed something, in my opinion yes you did. While it might seem logical for the American Army to join in in the Far East and Pacific campaigns, politically this is a no no. The American Army wants to expand and flex its wings and become a real Army like the Germans, Russians, French even the god dam Limeys. They want to play with tanks and big guns, not fight a minor campaign as second fiddle to the USN & USMC, on a bunch of islands in the Pacific. They want to deploy Army’s made up of multiple Corps, of numerous devisions, not be the junior partner only getting two stars, where as in Europe there is the chance of three or even four star appointments. While there isn’t at the present time anywhere where the army can fight the mechanical war they want to, hopefully there soon will be. And in the meantime, they can concentrate on expanding the present army, acquiring all the kit that they need, and preparing for the war they want. Let the navy and the marines play on the islands in the Pacific, they will be ready to intervene in Europe and show the world, just how fantastic the US Army is, the best in the world, with the most brilliant generals, and better equipped than any other army in history.

RR.
 
11 ind div
6th bde
15th bde
28th bde
9th ind div
8th bde
22nd bde
9th bde
29th bde
100th Light Tank Squadron (29th Jan OTL)
10th bde (Krohcol)
8th div aif
22nd bde
27th bde
16th bde
8th Division Cavalry Regiment.
9th div aif
20th bde
9th Divisional Cavalry
24th (14 dec)
26th (21 dec)
12th bde (ind)
11th Bn RTR
18th div(25 dec) (13-29 Jan OTL)

The above is my try to go over the update and list the forces in Malaya. Bit hard when the author tries to hide 2 extra divisions in the existing ones :) (5th ind and AIF).
Those in red are the additional forces.
 
10 December 1941. “The Ledge”, Thailand.
10 December 1941. “The Ledge”, Thailand.

Lieutenant Stan Alden’s war had been ‘interesting’ so far. He had been away two days, fought an engagement and returned to base. He was sitting trying to write to his parents at home, knowing that the censor would probably tear it up. It had begun at the stroke of midnight as 8 December began. He got orders over the R/T to move off, leading Krohcol into Thailand. Alden was a bit of a history buff, but for the life of him he couldn’t remember any time in the past that the British had invaded Thailand. But there he was, in a Matilda II tank, at the forefront of a strong force crossing the Thai border.

There were some light tanks and armoured cars in the column, but Brigadier Thomas ‘Pete’ Rees wanted the heavy armour of the Infantry Tanks at the front. His reasoning had proven sound when, as soon as they crossed the border, they were fired upon. The standing order was to return fire, so the three Matilda IIs pushed through towards Betong working over the surrounding jungle with their machine guns. A few trees had been felled over the road, hoping to delay the invasion force, but these were simply crushed under the heavy tanks’ treads.

Rees had 4th Battalion 10th Baluch Regiment sweep alongside the tanks. The Thai Police and volunteers opposing the British invasion were lightly armed, and the sheer invincibility of the tanks and the overwhelming firepower of the tanks and infantry combined, were just too much for the Thais to bear. A few sepoys were killed, but by the time the tanks rolled into Betong itself, the level of opposition had almost disappeared, in fact, a constable of the Thai police came forward to apologise for the ‘mistake’.

Lieutenant Alden had wanted to try to explain why it wasn’t really an invasion, after all Thailand was actually being invaded by the Japanese, and the British were coming to their aid. Instead, five hundred rounds of ammunition had done their talking for them. Passing Betong, there was another 26 miles before they arrived at their objective. At a comfortable 10 miles an hour, Alden’s troop arrived at the Patani river just after 04:00hrs on 8 December.

Brigadier Rees, after consultations with Major Dinwiddie (CO 45th Field Company Royal Bengal Sappers and Miners), decided to send a mobile force forward of the planned demolitions to the road. They would need to buy time for the Field Company should the Japanese arrive before the work was complete. One of the Matilda IIs would be part of that, and Lt Alden volunteered. A couple of armoured cars from 3rd Cavalry, with the carrier platoon of 2nd Bn Highland Light Infantry, were already forward of the main column reconnoitering the road. Alden came across one of the carriers on his way, the corporal reporting that they’d found this to be about the best position to throw up a road block.

Alden’s tank, two 2-pdr anti-tank guns, two Vickers HMG teams, and two companies of 2nd HLI began to prepare their positions. Major Robertson from 2nd HLI took command of the forward group. The HLI men had fought at the battle of Keren in the East African campaign, so they had a fair idea of how best to site a blocking force, especially with the bulk of an Infantry Tank ready to stand in the middle of the road. Robertson had brought most of the platoon’s 2-inch mortar teams together to provide a concentration of mortar fire when it was needed. The place the 3rd Cavalry had picked was indeed a good position, there was a sheer drop on the right, and a good view down the road.

A section each of the Cavalry and the carrier platoon carried on further along the road to give as much warning as possible to the roadblock of advancing Japanese. One enterprising serjeant in the carrier platoon had ‘borrowed’ some explosives from the Sappers and promised to leave a few problems for the Japanese, so that they’d have time to get back to the main force.

The rest of the day had passed quietly. The sappers went about their business along the Ledge, while the infantry prepared positions to counter any flanking movement over the hills after the road was blasted. At Robertson’s roadblock, there was time to prepare good solid positions. The motor transport was already facing back they way they had come. Robertson had worked out a fairly simple set of signals so that each unit would know when to disengage, get back to their transport and hightail it back to the main position before the road was blown. Alden’s tank would be the last to leave, protecting the rear of the force. Once his tank was past the demolitions, the sappers would blow the road in such a way that it would take enormous efforts to repair it.

The morning of 9th December had continued in much the same way. The only excitement had been some Japanese planes flying overhead. The whole force had done its best to camouflage itself and as far as anyone could see they had been successful. Because of the terrain radio communications was sporadic, and there was a dearth of radios generally. Alden had played around a bit with the tank’s radio trying to pick up anything within range. Just before 10:00hrs the distant sound of explosions and firing could be heard, followed by silence then some more. Major Robertson ordered his force to stand to, and sent a messenger on a motorcycle back to Brigadier Rees to report contact.

At 10.45hrs a carrier appeared on the road ahead and approached at its top speed. There were four wounded men in the rear and the corporal in charge, reported that a strong Japanese force had been seen heading up the road from the direction of Yala. A couple of the armoured cars from 3rd Cavalry had gone as far as Yala and had spoken to Thai police who reported that a Japanese force had landed at Pattani in the early hours of the previous morning. The cavalry had tried to keep ahead of the Japanese while keeping an eye on them. When they got back to where the carrier platoon was wiring a bridge, they had put on a small ambush, blowing the bridge when a Japanese tank was crossing it. After a brief firefight they had withdrawn at speed to the next site that the serjeant with the explosives had identified.

Again, they had done the same thing, but the firefight had got too hot. The four wounded men had got their injuries there to some kind of mortar barrage, three others had been killed. One of the Armoured Cars had been damaged and abandoned and one of the carriers destroyed. The corporal had been ordered to bring the wounded back, and report the contact. The rest of the carriers and armoured cars were behind him, but the serjeant had one more bit of mischief planned.

Not long after the carrier with the wounded had left them, another explosion and machine gun fire could be heard, a good bit closer. The remaining armoured cars and carriers appeared, obviously at top speed. They carried straight on through Robertson’s position, except one armoured car. The 3rd Cavalry Jemadar reported that the Japanese force consisted of at least a company of tanks and he estimated it was probably about the strength of a regiment, though he had only counted one Battalion’s worth personally. Major Robertson thanked him, and waved him off back to the main position.

Lieutenant Alden talked to his crew about what he wanted from them. If there were Japanese tanks, then the intelligence they had about them was that the 2-pdr would be more than adequate to deal with them. As far as he knew, they didn’t carry a gun that would be a threat to the frontal armour, so they should be pretty safe for the most part. Alden’s and Robertson’s orders were clear. The driver had spent the morning walking back over the route he would have to reverse along for about a mile before there was space to turn.

The motorcycle messenger arrived back with word that the sappers were running final checks, so Robertson’s force wouldn’t have to stay much more than an hour before heading back. A quick Officers’ Call followed so that all the information could be passed on to each element of the force and any other questions dealt with. A section of HLI troops were ahead with a view beyond the main position’s outlook. They had orders to get a rough estimate of what was coming up the road, then return, preferably without being spotted.

The four men arrived breathlessly a few minutes before noon. They had counted three light tanks with about a company of men, then a gap of about two hundred yards, then a bigger force, with at least five tanks. Most of the infantry were on foot, but there was some motor transport somewhere behind them, they could hear the grinding of gears. Robertson thanked them, ordered back to Motor Transport to get water and something to eat. Then they could rejoin their platoon.

The Company Sergeant-Majors had spent the morning going round the HLI men’s positions making sure everyone had had something to eat and drink. They also reminded the men why there was an elephant of their cap badge and reminded them of the 74th of Foot’s stand at Assaye. The men of the 74th would be watching down on the work that would be done today, and they had better be bloody proud, or else. The warning was left open ended, but the vast majority of the men had seen action before, and had a veteran’s eye for where things were, what their field of fire was, and the signals to watch out for.

The intermittent rain showers passed for the moment and Alden, watching the road through his binoculars, began to see movement through the haze. Sure enough, there were three tanks coming up the road. Tank recognition skills weren’t Alden’s strong point, but his gunner called them as ‘tin cans’. Robertson had noted that the presence of the Matilda II would be noticed at just over 1000 yards. Range markers had been laid out down the road to aid the defensive fire. At 1000 yards, the gunner noted that he was ‘on’, so Alden quietly said, ‘Fire!’

The leading tin can stopped dead. They couldn’t see it, but the shell had penetrated the armour and gone straight through the driver and bounced around inside the tank killing the gunner and commander. As no smoke could be seen, the gunner put another two rounds through the dead tank, just to be sure. The effect on the Japanese was to respond rapidly. They’d already been ambushed on the road, and the leading company spread out and started moving forward quickly. The other two light tanks managed to push the destroyed tank out of the way, and were providing covering fire for the infantry, with their 7.7mm MG and 37mm main gun.

Alden’s gunner hit the second tank almost as soon as it cleared the dead tank. A shot through the turret seemed to silence the main gun, though the forward machine gun was still firing, and the tank was still moving. Another two strikes knocked it out, though there had also been two misses which had caused some swearing. At four hundred yards the 2-inch mortars dropped their loads, scattering the Japanese troops, most of whom disappeared into the jungle to the side of the road.

This was exactly what Robertson had guessed would happen. He had D Company prepared to counter a flanking movement, and one of the Vickers HMGs was supporting them. 18 Platoon were furthest forward, and soon the noise of their Bren gun teams spraying the jungle and the rifle sections putting lots of lead down range signalled that they were in contact. The platoon OC, Lieutenant Bill Hamilton, blew his whistle three times to signal his men to get ready to pull back. On hearing the whistle blown twice as many men as possible threw hand grenades towards the enemy and immediately withdrew. One long whistle told the other platoons of D Company that 18 Platoon had successfully disengaged. These signals were followed by a Very Light to have the rest of D Company disengage.

The men returned to the road and immediately headed for their lorries and were the first to move back past the Ledge. C Company, with Alden’s tank, covered their withdrawal, and that of the two anti-tank guns and Vickers teams. The third Japanese tank had been dispatched by Alden’s tank and the co-axial Besa kept up a continual fire down the road, and the gunner occasionally took a shot with the 2-pdr to keep the Japanese honest.

Major Robertson fired the green flare that told everyone else to head for the motor transport. As C Company began to disengage, Alden warned the driver to be ready to pull back. The loader noted that they were running low on MG ammo, so it was just as well. Alden was watching back and forth, calling targets to the front and checking for the signal that the rest of the MT had left. The driver revved the engine as the tank was bracketed by mortar shells. Alden told him to calm down, but he had another look to see if the signal was made. The red flare burst and Alden said ‘move.’ The driver stalled the engine. The loader and the gunner cursed, more and more bangs and things rattling off the tank, and the low ammunition count were getting to them all.

Alden calmed spoke to the driver, ‘take a breath, and start it up, just like usual. Don’t panic, there’s plenty of time.’ The engine fired and the tank began to move backwards, Alden said, ‘right lads, nice and easy, short bursts until were out of contact. Put a few 2-pdr rounds down range occasionally. Everything’s going to be fine. Gunner, keep your eyes forward, I’ll direct Harry back down the road.’

Having stalled the engine once, the driver was concentrating hard not to do anything daft, especially with a long drop down the hill on one side of the road. Alden calmly called for corrections and the Matilda II broke contact with the Japanese. In five minutes, they reached the place where the tank could turn around. Once they were driving away, with the gun trained over the rear of the tank towards the enemy, everybody began to breathe again. Soon they were smiling, especially as they passed along the part of the Ledge that was going to be blown up.

An hour later, as the leading Japanese troops and vehicles passed into the blast area, a satisfying series of cracks and bangs caused almost a mile of road to disappear from view. A long cheer from the men of 10th Indian Brigade and attached forces echoes over the hills. The plan had worked, the Japanese weren’t getting along that road any time soon.

With the mission accomplished, Brigadier Rees had consulted some of the Thai police and locals for their local knowledge. The road that had been destroyed was the best road (which wasn’t saying much) between Yala and Betong. He didn’t want to have his Brigade flanked by lesser roads or paths through the hills. There were indeed trails and pathways used by the locals, and while they weren’t much use to motor transport, an enterprising infantry commander could certainly use them to get round the flank. A couple of times in Ethiopia, those kind of trails known only to locals, had proved very helpful, and once, quite dangerous when the Italians used one.

Rees decided to leave one Battalion of infantry (4th Bn 10th Baluch Regiment), with some heavy weapons to hold the area and try to dissuade the Japanese to fix the road. The majority of his Brigade he wanted to take back to Betong, where he could block access to the Malayan road network. Rees also thought that the other Brigades of 11th Indian Division at Jitra would likely need reinforcing at some point. If 10th Brigade was at Betong, or even back at Kroh, then he could pivot his force in whichever direction the Division needed him.

The three Infantry tanks were ordered back to Kroh immediately where they could meet up with their section of the Light Aid Detachment to do some of the maintenance which was always required after travelling 100 miles. Lieutenant Alden had led his troop of three Matilda IIs back along the road and back over the border. His invasion of Thailand had been short-lived, just two days. He couldn’t help wondering whether “Veni, Vidi, Vici” was a description he could use in his letter to describe the previous two days. Just like Julius Caesar’s visit to Britain, it hadn't lasted long.
 
Hmm big advantage of the Burma invasion not going in is going to be that the Burma road will stay open longer for all the good it will do.
I think it would've done some good irregardless of how much of the supplies are stolen or misused or repurposed for Chiang Kai-Shek's own interests. Having the Burma Road remain open eliminates the need for the very costly and dangerous Hump Airlift. Maybe even Operation Matterhorn would make sense with the improved logistics. Being able to ship more supplies and vehicles into China is going to benefit Allied operations in China.

The British and Commonwealth forces stopping the Japanese army from over running Burma will prevent the circumstances that brought about the Bengal Famine.
 
Top