Nobunaga’s Ambition Realized: Dawn of a New Rising Sun

Chapter 79: Manji War Part I - A Clash of Titans and a Conflict of Attrition

Chapter 79: Manji War Part I - A Clash of Titans and a Conflict of Attrition


Throughout the 1650s, Sakuma Moritora had focused on integrating the Ainu and other indigenous tribes in southern Karafuto and expanding Japanese presence in the area. The increasingly profitable fur trade expanded as a result of Japan’s expansion into the far north and fur trappers and traders began to venture further beyond to northern Karafuto and the Amur region, where they increasingly came into contact with the Jurchens in the Amur khanate and recent Russian arrivals from Okhotsk. Moritora and Japan overall were fated to engage with the two groups in the future, and indeed the rumblings of confrontation on the mainland could begin to be felt. However, for the time being, Japan remained uninvolved in these relations and Moritora’s focus in 1659 was to the south in his capacity as Chinjufu shogun. In early November 1659, his army of 30,000 entered Echigo province, consisting of the retinues of the various Oshu lords, chiefly among them being his and that of the Date, Mogami, and Nanbu clans. Accompanying him personally as part of his guard and strikeforce were 1,000 Ainu mercenaries from Ezo and Karafuto who were armed with harpoons and firearms and acted as melee shock troopers complementing the regular samurai infantry and cavalry, musketeers, and cannons.

He quickly approached Shibata Castle where Oda Nagaaki was located with a few thousand men. The young lord sent messengers to his father, who was gathering a large army near the Echigo-Etchu border in anticipation of Moritora’s arrival. Upon receiving news from his son, Tomoaki departed to confront the Tiger of the North, now commanding an army of 22,000 which included 4,000 of his elite French-influenced line infantry. By the time he arrived, Nagaaki had been forced out of Shibata Castle by Moritora and joined his father’s moving army. Tomoaki strived forward and moved towards the northern army, which was still in the area consolidating their victory. Moritora quickly received word, however, and prepared for battle. Leaving a few hundred men in Shibata Castle, he arranged into battle formation on the plains of Ijimino (五十公野). He placed himself on the frontlines of the right wing on the battlefield along with his Ainu mercenaries and handpicked samurai mounted warriors, while his younger brother Torahide oversaw the main body of musketeers and yari ashigaru in the middle along with the reserves. Mogami Yoshisato led his and those from minor clans behind the Chinjufu shogun while the new Date lord Tsugumune’s (伊達嗣宗) older brother, Tamura Muneyoshi (田村宗良) led the left wing. Tomoaki’s arrival soon followed, and the rebel Oda lord quickly arranged his forces across from Moritora’s position. He chose to place all of his cavalry on the wings except for a few hundred reserves of his close retainers in the center, the right and left being led by Sassa Katsuoki (佐々勝興), the younger brother of Sassa clan head Sassa Katsutoyo, and Sanada Yukitoshi respectively. Tomoaki, in the center himself, placed his elite infantry at the very front, supported by artillery, yari ashigaru, and swordsmen.​

WTLrWlHo-2fHgzMgRtS8_a_BryfJG930YARJiiDsCUut2W3E9RTWuORJHD5POzgJiZQI3E3DBIEEEGU47SGeROueI1LpwiBWCYnejiMNF2GPv5VFpzNibsf8-pa8Jqt1sbglxO0CPPAIq5fKQT789Qs


Salmon= Tomoaki rebel army, Blue= Moritora Chinjufu-Azuchi army​

The battle began in the late morning when Moritora gave the signal and initiated a headstrong charge, with the rest of his army soon following his lead. Tomoaki’s wings followed while strategically Tomoaki slowly approached the enemy’s center, stopping thrice in case they needed to brace for impact in a sign of brilliant discipline from his men before readying their gunfire. At his signal, the Chinjufu army’s center was showered with cannonfire and musketballs unlike anything seen in Japan and the former began to suffer big losses. Things were not as impressive for the rebels elsewhere, however, for on their right the Date and Sassa fought viciously to a standstill, both clans known for their martial prowess. Meanwhile, Sakuma Moritora and the Chinjufu right wing was busy overrunning the rebel left wing, made up of Tomoaki’s men from the Nagao clan and Shinano province. It was here that the Ainu mercenaries proved their metal, tackling samurai off their horses and spearing the enemy with their harpoons. After Sanada Yukitoshi was killed, the rebel left wing broke into a panicked retreat, Moritora now turning to the suddenly vulnerable center. Seeing the precarious situation he was now in, Tomoaki quickly gathered his reserves and turned to meet Moritora. At the same time, he ordered the artillery in the center to be rotated to the left to support his efforts. Tomoaki’s swift actions enabled an effective counter against Moritora’s flanking charge although the latter would still begin to push back the former. Feeling the pressure on all sides, Tomoaki decided to withdraw while he could, although he was forced to abandon much of his cannons to the enemy. Ultimately, the battle would end with Tomoaki’s army suffering 7,000 casualties while Moritora’s army suffered 3,000.

The Battle of Ijimino (五十公野の戦い) resulted in a pro-Azuchi victory as Tomoaki would be forced to retreat further south. Nevertheless, Moritora had experienced his toughest battle yet fought and the perseverance of the rebels allowed them to retain their unity and fight another day, preventing the rebellion from collapsing. This allowed the more favorable conditions in other theaters to play out and induce a stalemate for the rest of the year while giving the rebellion time to grow even further. The Sassa and Mori clans shielded Echigo from the west and south. Meanwhile, Shibata Katsuoki’s army in Kaga province was left in a precarious position, unable to pass through Etchu province while strangled of reinforcements from the Kinki region due to the rise of arms by the Ikeda, Kudō, and Tokugawa clans. Konoe Toshishige and his government was also preoccupied with conducting espionage across different daimyo households, the imperial court, and even the Church of Yamato. Azuchi also focused on building up the defenses of Owari and Gifu provinces against an expected Tokugawa offensive. The early months of 1660, however, did see more movement in central and western Japan. Western shogun Kitabatake Takanaga deployed his men against the Kudō in Iga province. Meanwhile, Toshishige ordered an army to be directed against the Ikeda in Settsu province and the Azuchi navy, led by naval shogun Kuki Takasue, to blockade the province. Miyoshi Yasunori also began to march upon Tosa province and the pro-Tomoaki Chosokabe clan under the authority of the kōbu kanpaku. These movements would set up months of protracted fighting and attrition as well as extended sieges.

Things would pick up in the north and east once again when spring arrived. The Tokugawa, led by the lord Noriyasu himself and numbering 15,000, entered Owari province with the objective of capturing Gifu and cutting off the entire east from Azuchi as well as the main communication line between the regime and Shibata Katsuoki’s army. Noriyasu also hoped that Oda samurai with sympathies for Tomoaki would rise up and join his force. However, this last assumption would be proven wrong in his attempt at capturing Kiyosu Castle. The entire populace, regardless of how they felt about the kōbu kanpaku, viewed the Tokugawa siege as an attack upon the Oda clan and its head Manchiyo himself and rallied to the defense of the castle, and yet another engagement would become bogged down amidst a siege. As for Echigo, the beating heart of the rebellion, Sakuma Moritora’s men had made small gains throughout the winter. Realizing that winning a field battle against the Chinjufu general was next to impossible, Tomoaki switched tactics and began engaging in guerrilla warfare in the mountainous forests of Echigo. The early spring did see a major battle between Shibata Katsuoki and Sassa Katsutoyo near the village of Shirakawa (白河村) in Hida province, which resulted in a Shibata, pro-Azuchi victory.​

fknjXVBGXsSjxKlTCIZkyFWhkMALG3P-oD3TeyZYzSM_Rli5hmeniXc1lD3pfL9vnArhuR1Fv-zY3tivrH_02e5aoLhcKD40TKHo2Ubk6zDBcsl4GgfKk6pGC2kT8d8fVTJAFxZrCbxSvO1mYXmxCrw


Modern day Kiyosu Castle, a rallying cry for the people and samurai of Owari in 1660​

In April 1660, the war had descended into a series of sieges and attrition-heavy conflict rather than the decisive maneuvers and battles that defined the Furuwatari War more significantly. This in turn benefited the prospects of the government, for although Tomoaki’s rebel faction were putting up a fierce resistance, most of Japan nominally still followed the leadership of Konoe Toshishige and his regency over the Oda clan and Manchiyo as well as the imperial court and it looked likely that numbers would eventually triumph. However, Japan was just a month away from two incidents that would change everything, and one of them would be triggered by an old enemy that had been eyeing the situation for months: Spain.​
 
Last edited:
At this point, I want to Spain to attack. Purely to make Japan get its arse into gear and properly unify.
Yeah I defo agree. It's about time for the two sides to compromise and having a common enemy is the perfect thing to do so. The fact that the armies are already raised is great for Japan too.
 
Yeah I defo agree. It's about time for the two sides to compromise and having a common enemy is the perfect thing to do so. The fact that the armies are already raised is great for Japan too.
Ah, but then doesn't this end up being like the United Front in China during World War II? The two sides team up to kick out Spain and allies, and then one side takes the brunt of the damage and ends up losing to the other side when they inevitably go back to fighting each other?
 
Ah, but then doesn't this end up being like the United Front in China during World War II? The two sides team up to kick out Spain and allies, and then one side takes the brunt of the damage and ends up losing to the other side when they inevitably go back to fighting each other?
Yeah it is very possible it goes much like the United Front expect that the Japanese don't need any help theoretically (even tho I'd think Japan would gladly accept help from the Brits, Dutch and French).

Tbf I think it could be the start of friendly relations between Japan and Britain which would be great.
 
Yeah it is very possible it goes much like the United Front expect that the Japanese don't need any help theoretically (even tho I'd think Japan would gladly accept help from the Brits, Dutch and French).

Tbf I think it could be the start of friendly relations between Japan and Britain which would be great.
Anglo-Japanese relations are already friendly (and Japan tried to get England to fight the Spanish during the Iberian-Japanese War) but they’re not as deep and extensive as they are with the Dutch or French.
 
Hopefully our relationship with the English/British will stay friendly but with how they have a history of tricks and underhand tactics (especially with the East India Company), So their friendly relationship will decrease in the next few centuries but who knows.
 
Anglo-Japanese relations are already friendly (and Japan tried to get England to fight the Spanish during the Iberian-Japanese War) but they’re not as deep and extensive as they are with the Dutch or French.
Tbf they'd have to split the region with someone and being allies to the Dutch and British would be a good first step to it.
 
Tbf I wonder how would weapons evolve as time goes on too. We should see weapons like pike and shot (yari and tanegashima?), and I think yari would split into the partisan esque ones and the more pike esque ones, where the more partisan looking yari would be used to tackle armoured opponents (with the flanges shaped more like spikes so it could pierce armour) for samurai to tackle other samurai, and kanobo would be used for armoured opponents too. The harpoons the Ainu used would be like billhooks where it's easy to manufacture, but I see them adding a yari head on the main shaft to increase killing efficiency, which would be an interesting weapon and an exotic weapon which would be brought back to Europe. Finally, I wonder how swords would evolve. I could see katana being an infantry sword, while tachi are used more by the cavalry, and adaptation of the weapon for the two roles would make sense. Nagamaki as a greatsword and anti cavalry esque weapon would make sense too, but I think they'd be specialised units in yari/harpoon formations instead of units in their own right much like the greatsword users in Landsknechts.

Tbf one weapon I don't see coming up much would be the naginata. They'd be rarely used since close formations mean yari is the optimum weapon and as they fight Europeans the trend is going to continue. Kanobo probably would be phased out when armour gets phased out and guns become better too.
 
Last edited:
Is Japan gonna lose the Phillippines? Sadge. Hopefully this war finally kicks into the Oda's numbskulls to properly centralize Japan and curtail all the Daimyo and their cadets.
 
Is Japan gonna lose the Phillippines? Sadge. Hopefully this war finally kicks into the Oda's numbskulls to properly centralize Japan and curtail all the Daimyo and their cadets.
Perhaps. But considering that Tomoaki is salmon which usually is the central gov's colour I think Tomoaki is going to win, so more colonisation is going to happen, and I think it's likely that when Spain fires the first shots the two armies in Japan will temporarily stop to fight the Spanish.
 
Perhaps. But considering that Tomoaki is salmon which usually is the central gov's colour I think Tomoaki is going to win, so more colonisation is going to happen, and I think it's likely that when Spain fires the first shots the two armies in Japan will temporarily stop to fight the Spanish.
We can only hope.
 
Tbf I wonder how would weapons evolve as time goes on too. We should see weapons like pike and shot (yari and tanegashima?), and I think yari would split into the partisan esque ones and the more pike esque ones, where the more partisan looking yari would be used to tackle armoured opponents (with the flanges shaped more like spikes so it could pierce armour) for samurai to tackle other samurai, and kanobo would be used for armoured opponents too. The harpoons the Ainu used would be like billhooks where it's easy to manufacture, but I see them adding a yari head on the main shaft to increase killing efficiency, which would be an interesting weapon and an exotic weapon which would be brought back to Europe. Finally, I wonder how swords would evolve. I could see katana being an infantry sword, while tachi are used more by the cavalry, and adaptation of the weapon for the two roles would make sense. Nagamaki as a greatsword and anti cavalry esque weapon would make sense too, but I think they'd be specialised units in yari/harpoon formations instead of units in their own right much like the greatsword users in Landsknechts.

Tbf one weapon I don't see coming up much would be the naginata. They'd be rarely used since close formations mean yari is the optimum weapon and as they fight Europeans the trend is going to continue. Kanobo probably would be phased out when armour gets phased out and guns become better too.
At this point, a version of pike and shot has been adopted with many domains as well as the shogunal armies of the daijo-fu being influenced by the continental reforms seen in the Imperal Liberties' War and the Franco-Spanish War. Tomoaki's elite infantry is an example of line infantry tactics even being incorporated to some extent. The trajectory Japanese military tactics and equipment is headed can best be compared to the Carolean infantry.
 
At this point, a version of pike and shot has been adopted with many domains as well as the shogunal armies of the daijo-fu being influenced by the continental reforms seen in the Imperal Liberties' War and the Franco-Spanish War. Tomoaki's elite infantry is an example of line infantry tactics even being incorporated to some extent. The trajectory Japanese military tactics and equipment is headed can best be compared to the Carolean infantry.
Hmm that makes sense, considering that it's around time for early line tactics to pop up. Line tactics do have their own problems tho especially when they get hit in the flanks by cavalry. Would we see shock infantry in those places to repel cavalry charges?

I also wonder would the Japanese use the socket bayonet a little earlier than the Europeans as they'd be fighting the Spaniards soon and a general thinking that a plug bayonet is terrible would make sense. Maybe Moritora inventing the idea would make sense?

Ps how often would the nagamaki be used? I can still see them being quite nice as skirmish weapons.
 
Last edited:
Hmm that makes sense, considering that it's around time for early line tactics to pop up. Line tactics do have their own problems tho especially when they get hit in the flanks by cavalry. Would we see shock infantry in those places to repel cavalry charges?

I also wonder would the Japanese use the socket bayonet a little earlier than the Europeans as they'd be fighting the Spaniards soon and a general thinking that a plug bayonet is terrible would make sense. Maybe Moritora inventing the idea would make sense?

Ps how often would the nagamaki be used? I can still see them being quite nice as skirmish weapons.
Full line infantry tactics are only present in Tomoaki’s elite force and in any case they’re placed in the center with cavalry in the wings. Being that they’re an elite force, they’re also full trained to switch to melee fighting when they need to.

Socket bayonets are not gonna be invented earlier by the Japanese sadly. If anything the prized tradition of sword fighting among the samurai as well as the plentiful number of yari ashigaru makes bayonet usage in Japanese armies nearly nonexistent.

All these questions beg the need for a military technology and evolution chapter for sure. What I can say is that nagamaki swords are fast falling out of use in the home islands but still serve a function in Bireitou and Luson with the higher percentage of forested areas and lower percentage of open plains.
 
What would be interesting is when bayonets inevitably make their way to Japan, there are some yari ashigaru that “evolve” to use guns and treat bayonets in a similar fashion to their traditional weapons. This may be totally unrealistic I’m not familiar with melee combat.
 
Full line infantry tactics are only present in Tomoaki’s elite force and in any case they’re placed in the center with cavalry in the wings. Being that they’re an elite force, they’re also full trained to switch to melee fighting when they need to.

Socket bayonets are not gonna be invented earlier by the Japanese sadly. If anything the prized tradition of sword fighting among the samurai as well as the plentiful number of yari ashigaru makes bayonet usage in Japanese armies nearly nonexistent.
Hmm that makes sense, I still do think that the Japanese would eventually adopt socket bayonets (at the mid 18th century at the latest?) bc dropping the gun and fighting in melee means the infantry would have to recover the guns in situations where a counterattack from one of the wings occurs.

I still do find it weird that no one in Japan uses plug bayonets bc both the Europeans and Chinese would have used it for almost a century tho, but the Scottish Highlanders do exist, so perhaps plug bayonets are just rarely used and that socket bayonets pop up at around early to mid 18th century and become standard in the 19th century with some regiments still doing things the old fashioned way as shock infantry?

Seeing something like jukendo pop up would be very cool, it would have a bunch of influences from different European countries ittl, and there would be something wholly to Japan itself as time passes.
All these questions beg the need for a military technology and evolution chapter for sure. What I can say is that nagamaki swords are fast falling out of use in the home islands but still serve a function in Bireitou and Luson with the higher percentage of forested areas and lower percentage of open plains.
Yeah I love that this tl focuses on stuff like this, and something like military tech and tactics are something that're not focused on in TLs like this.
 
Top