Recent content by Jan Olbracht

  1. No Nazism (and maybe no WWII) - What is the ultimate fate of the Second Polish Republic?

    Nope. Poland would not give up Corridor without a war. Poland was more determined to fight for independence that Czechoslovakia and would resist.
  2. List of Alternate Monarchs and Aristocratic Lineage II

    Yes, they're obviously small kids when Sigismund II dies. Magnates' paradise.
  3. No Nazism (and maybe no WWII) - What is the ultimate fate of the Second Polish Republic?

    If such Germany demands Corridor, then war is imminent anyway, so is German-Soviet pact to ensure at least USSR's neutrality. Germans hated Poland much more than USSR, even right wing ones, and preffered 1914 borders over Polish buffer against Soviets.
  4. No Nazism (and maybe no WWII) - What is the ultimate fate of the Second Polish Republic?

    Blah, blah, blah evil dumb Poles would destroy themselves blah, blah, blah... If Germany invade Poland geopolitical domino would still fall same as OTL. UK & France have not declared war in Germany because of nazism, there were no death camps on 3 September 1939. They did it, because Germany...
  5. No Nazism (and maybe no WWII) - What is the ultimate fate of the Second Polish Republic?

    Without war? Nope. And if war happens result is roughly IOTL.
  6. List of Alternate Monarchs and Aristocratic Lineage II

    Another Louis d'Anjou & Elizabeth of Bosnia family tree: Elizabeth of Bosnia (1339-1387) m. Louis I (1326-1382) King of Hungary and Poland 1) Catherine (1370-1378) 2) Mary (1371-1433) Queen of Hungary, m. Sigismund (1368-1437) King of Bohemia and Hungary, Holy Roman Emperor 1) Elizabeth...
  7. Could the November Uprising of 1830 have succeeded?

    Neither side was satisfied in 1815, but Prussians were the real winners in the long run.
  8. Could the November Uprising of 1830 have succeeded?

    Rump state would be strongly opposed by Prussia & Austria, so for Alex it would be better to restore 1795 borders (with RE keeping just Białystok and Tarnopol). Bonus is, that Prussia and Austria would face serious troubles with their Polish population, especially the former, which within 1795...
  9. List of Alternate Monarchs and Aristocratic Lineage II

    Well, even hereditary monarchy like Sweden under Vasas saw 2 usurpations, GDL was usurped by Kazimierz Jagiellończyk against brother's will. And Polish nobles had to swear to Mary d'Anjou before, so nothing is guaranteed.
  10. List of Alternate Monarchs and Aristocratic Lineage II

    Take it into account: oldest son and intended heir (who even may be accepted as heir by nobles of all 4 realms or already crowned) of ATL Vladislaus III died not long before him. That makes succession more chaotic and split more likely.
  11. List of Alternate Monarchs and Aristocratic Lineage II

    OTL Władysław III practically lost Lithuania and neglected Poland after he moved to Buda. Such monstrosity would either collapse or monarch would barely be in control of most of his realm, having to ceede power to local councils. Casimir IV had seriuos trouble with Lithuania after he moved to...
  12. List of Alternate Monarchs and Aristocratic Lineage II

    Yes, he would, that is most logical thing he could do and pretty normal for the time.
  13. List of Alternate Monarchs and Aristocratic Lineage II

    Having multiple sons Władysław III would want to secure their future. Poland-Lithuania-Bohemia-Hungary moloch would be ungovernable anyway-it is receipe for eternal civil war. And IOTL Sigismund of Luxembourg was meant to split the thrones of Bohemia and Hungary if he had second daughter. And...
  14. List of Alternate Monarchs and Aristocratic Lineage II

    Hedwig d'Anjou (1374-1399) Queen of Poland, m. Vadislaus II Jogaila (ca. 1360-1434) Grand Duke of Lithuania, King of Poland 1) Vladislaus III (1399-1445) King of Poland 1434, King of Bohemia and Hungary (as Ladislaus V) 1437, m. Elizabeth of Luxembourg (1409-1442) [1] 1) Vladislaus (1427-1444)...
  15. Could the November Uprising of 1830 have succeeded?

    Obviously, losing a war against his own subject is not something, that any ruler of the time could afford, let alone Nicholas I. Older brother really left him in situation without good options with dubious gift of Polish throne. Otherwise by mid 19th century (when modern Polish nationalism...
Top